Look, I’ll be honest with you. Twenty years in the past, after I first started hanging around elite performers—Olympic athletes, fighter pilots, and CEOs staring down billion-dollar decisions—I bought into the myth, much like everybody else.
I’d watch someone sink a recreation-prevailing shot or make a split-second call that saved lives, and I’d assume, “Man, they’ve just been given something the rest of the people don’t.”
You know the feeling. We all do. When pressure hits its peak, a tiny fraction of people rise. The rest of us? We tighten up. We hesitate. We fall apart.
For many years, we have explained this gap with a tidy little label: “He was given the grasp gene.” Michael Jordan, Tom Brady, Derek Jeter—we communicate about them like they were born with some mystery weapon coded into their DNA.
But right here’s what I’ve discovered after decades of reading the neuroscience of excessive-stakes performance—and honest caution, it would mess with some things you notion had been actual:
The clutch gene doesn’t exist.
There’s no genetic sequence for hitting a buzzer-beater. No chromosome that codes for staying cool while everything’s on the line.
What does exist? Something extra interesting. A predictable, measurable neural mechanism that separates individuals who thrive under pressure from those who choke. And the exceptional component? It’s trainable. We’ll get into exactly the way it works in a minute.
The Mythology of the “Clutch Gene”
Let’s start by taking apart this idea. Sports media loves the term “clutch gene.” Player hits a big shot, and everyone nods wisely: “He’s just got it.”
But here’s what Dr. John F. Murray, a clinical and sports psychologist, told ESPN: “Clutch gene is a myth. It’s been learned. They put in thousands of hours [preparing for] pressure situations, that they raise their performance in those situations”.
Jimbo Fisher, when he was coaching at Florida State, had maybe the best take on this. Talking approximately about his receiver Rashad Greene—a man who consistently showed up in massive moments—Fisher stated Greene definitely has the “power of education gene.”
Now, this isn’t just splitting hairs. The distinction actually matters. A lot.
If you buy the “clutch gene” story, you’re basically telling yourself: “I wasn’t born with it, so I’ll never have it.” And that belief? It becomes reality. You don’t even try.
But if you recognize that grasping overall performance is an ability—a neurological sample you may genuinely build—everything changes. Suddenly, it is no longer about destiny. It’s about work.
Why We Choke: The Neuroscience of Failure
So if champions aren’t born different, why do most of us crumble when the heat turns up?
Recent neuroscience research—I’m talking studies using 7 Tesla functional MRI, which is basically the Hubble telescope of brain scanners—has given us some pretty clear answers.
A 2024 study in Neuroscience Research put people in a “Jackpot” condition where they could win huge rewards for performing well. Simple enough, right? Except that success rates tanked. They choked.
Here’s what the scans actually showed:
Right before action—in that preparation phase—two specific brain regions lit up abnormally in people who went on to fail:
First, the cerebellum. For a long time, we thought this was just the brain’s coordination center. But it turns out the cerebellum houses what researchers call “internal models”—basically, the brain’s best guess at how our actions will play out. Under pressure, that internal model goes haywire.
Second, the middle temporal visual area (hMT+). This region handles visual motion. Under pressure, it gets overactive in ways that just… mess things up.
The study authors concluded that choking comes from “the cerebellum’s internal model modulation by psychological pressure, manifested through improper sensory attenuation”. Which is a fancy way of saying: pressure scrambles your brain’s ability to predict what’s coming and filter out noise. You get clumsy. You hesitate. You miss.
The Motor Cortex “Sweet Spot”
Another 2024 exam, this one in Neuron, looked at rhesus monkeys doing a problematic achievement task for uniquely sized rewards. Small praise, medium praise, massive praise—overall performance kept getting better. But when researchers dropped a “jackpot” on them? The monkeys choked.
They recorded neural activity right from the motor cortex. And here’s the kicker: neural activity scaled with reward size. More reward, more neural firing. But there’s this “optimal zone” for movement preparation. Moderate rewards pushed activity into that zone. Jackpot rewards pushed it right past—out of the sweet spot.
The researchers call this the “neural bias” hypothesis. Your brain doesn’t shut down under pressure. It actually over-corrects. It tries too damn hard. And that trying-too-hard shoves you out of your performance groove.
The Working Memory Hijack
There’s another piece here, too: working memory.
When you’re under pressure, anxious thoughts start crowding your mental workspace. They eat up the limited space you have for actually doing the task.
This explains something kind of fascinating. Researchers once tested students with different working memory capacities on math problems—first under low pressure, then under high pressure.
Low pressure? No surprise: the high-capacity students crushed it, outperforming everyone else.
High pressure? Totally different story. The high-capacity students performed the same as the low-capacity ones.
Why? Because those high-capacity students had enough mental room to hold their anxiety alongside the math. The pressure thoughts moved right in and took over that extra space. The low-capacity students? They didn’t have room for the anxiety anyway. Their performance just chugged along as usual.
What Champions Do Differently: The Clutch State
Okay, so we know what choking seems like in the mind. But what about the alternative aspect? What’s going on while someone rises to the event?
Christian Swann and his team published work in the Journal of Sports Sciences looking at this exact question. They studied athletes across the board—Olympic medalists, recreational competitors, everyone in between.
They found 12 characteristics of what they call the “clutch state”:
Heightened concentration
Intense effort
Heightened awareness
Perceptions of control
Automaticity (things just… happen)
Optimistic feelings
Enhanced motivation
Excitement (not anxiety)
Total absorption
Clear thoughts
Feeling “in the zone.”
Enjoyment
Here’s the thing that jumps out at me: none of these are magical. They’re not supernatural gifts from the gods. They’re mental states. And mental states? You can train them.
The Preparation Paradox
If there’s one thing twenty years in this field has taught me, it’s this: Clutch isn’t about what you do in the moment. It’s about what you did six months ago.
Trevor Moawad, who ran mental conditioning at Florida State, had a great line: “Clutch focuses too often on the fourth quarter; Rashad Greene is as good in the beginning as he is in the end”.
The athlete who hits the game-winner didn’t suddenly become magic. They practiced that shot ten thousand times. They visualized that exact moment ten thousand more. By the time the real thing rolled around, their brain didn’t have to think. It just ran the program that years of work had burned into its circuitry.
Rashad Greene himself put it simply: the practice he puts in the other six days of the week “seems to pay off in critical times”.
The Personality Factor: Neuroticism vs. Composure
I should be honest here. Is there any genetic piece to this?
Probably, yeah. A little.
While the “take hold of gene” is nonsense, a few character trends do have genetic roots. People high in neuroticism—tension, anxiety, and fearfulness—may definitely find it more difficult to calm themselves while the strain’s on.
But—and this is crucial—they could still educate themselves to perform. It’s just that the mental game takes more work. As one analysis put it, people low in neuroticism also feel anxiety and fear. The difference is “they can calm themselves with more ease”. And that ease? You can build it.
How to Train for Clutch: A 20-Year Expert’s Protocol
After two decades working with everyone from fighter pilots to Fortune 500 execs, I’ve boiled the science down to five practical steps. Here’s how you actually build a clutch.
Step 1: Pressure Simulation
You cannot learn to perform under pressure by only practicing when things are comfortable. You have to simulate the heat.
The military calls this “stress inoculation training.” They expose soldiers to simulated combat over and over until the nervous system stops panicking. When real combat comes, the brain says, “Oh, I know this. I’ve been here before.”
Whatever your field, create pressure in practice. Put something on the line. Make consequences for failure. Make your practice harder than the real thing ever will be.
Step 2: Visualization with Neural Specificity
Not all visualization is created equal. The kind that works? It actually engages the same neural circuits as real performance. You should feel the movements in your body. Your motor cortex should light up, not just your visual cortex.
Some elite athletes spend up to 30% of their training time in mental rehearsal. They’re not daydreaming. They’re building pathways.
Step 3: Pre-Performance Routines
I’ve never met a clutch performer who didn’t have some kind of pre-performance ritual. Breathing pattern. Physical sequence. Verbal cue. Something.
These routines do real neurological work. They anchor the brain, signaling “performance mode engaged.” They cut down the cognitive load of deciding what to do in the moment. The routine handles the transition; the brain focuses on execution.
Step 4: Cognitive Offloading
Remember the working memory stuff? Anxious thoughts eat mental bandwidth. One of the simplest fixes? Write it down.
Studies display that scholars who write about their concerns before a test perform considerably higher. The writing actions the anxiety out of running memory and onto paper. Frees up area for the real venture.
Before any excessive-stakes second, I even have my clients do a five-minute “brain unload.” Every fear, each fear, every “what if.” Then they near the notebook and move to perform.
Step 5: Process Focus, Not Outcome Focus
This might be the biggest one. Where your attention lives makes all the difference.
Chokers think about the outcome: “I have to make this shot.” “I can’t blow it.” “Everyone’s watching.”
Clutchers think about the process: “Feet shoulder-width apart.” “Eyes on the target.” “Breathe.”
Outcome focus activates the anxiety circuitry. Process focus keeps you in the motor execution network. Train yourself to shift attention to process cues when things get tight.
The Bottom Line
Look, I’ve watched limitless humans over twenty years—athletes, executives, and squaddies—cross from choking artists to grasp performers. Not because they found some hidden gene. Because they did the damn work.
They built the neural pathways through repetition. They simulated pressure until it stopped feeling like pressure. They developed workouts that anchored their fearful structures. They discovered consciousness through the technique in preference to the final results.
The clutch gene? Total myth.
But clutch performance? It’s real. And it’s available to anyone willing to pay the price of preparation.
The question isn’t whether you were born with “it.” The question is whether you’re willing to build it.
+ There are no comments
Add yours